Palmyra Homes for Sale

Palmyra Homes for Sale

Welcome to Palmyra, Missouri – a charming city nestled in the heart of Marion County, where small-town charm meets vibrant community spirit. Known for its rich history and friendly atmosphere, Palmyra offers a unique blend of rural tranquility and modern conveniences. With its picturesque landscapes, local parks, and a welcoming community, it’s no surprise that Palmyra has become a sought-after destination for families, retirees, and anyone looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life.

As you explore this delightful city, you’ll find a variety of homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and budgets. From cozy single-family residences perfect for first-time buyers to spacious multi-bedroom homes ideal for growing families, Palmyra’s real estate market has something for everyone. Many properties boast beautiful yards, modern amenities, and easy access to local schools, shopping, and dining options, making it easy to settle into the community.

In addition to its appealing homes, Palmyra is rich in local culture and history. Residents enjoy annual events, farmer’s markets, and community gatherings that foster a strong sense of belonging. Whether you’re strolling through the charming downtown area or enjoying the beauty of the nearby parks, you’ll quickly understand why so many choose to call Palmyra home.

If you’re ready to find your dream home in this delightful city, explore the listings of homes for sale in Palmyra, MO. Your new adventure awaits in this welcoming community, where every day feels like a breath of fresh air!

Newest Palmyra Homes for Sale

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ CA1045352 MLS

Would you like a two for one? Take a look at this 3 bed room 1 bath home with a full unfinished basement plus a mother-in-law's quarter that has 2 bed rooms and 1 bath. Both homes are leaving all appliances. Both homes have vinyl fencing around the whole property. The main house has laundry in the basement which doubles as great additional storage. Main house has replacement windows and vinyl siding. The mother-in-law's quarters has metal siding and roof and replacement windows. This property has so much potential and options, come take a look and see how it could meet your needs.

487 W Lewis Street, Palmyra

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ CA1045221 MLS

Are you looking for an older home that you can make your own?? This home boast of the old wood trim and doors. Beautiful staircase. The rooms in the house are roomy. Home has hardwood floors under the carpet through out. Beveled window on front door. The garage is a 1 car garage that has tons of room on the West side. Come check this house and add your loving TLC to to make it your home!!! HOME IS BEING SOLD AS IS

220 S Main Street, Palmyra

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ CA1044995 MLS

COMING SOON! Showings start Thursday, 7/9/2026. Welcome home to this elegant 4bd/2.5ba ranch offering over 3,500 sq ft of beautifully designed living space, along w/a huge loft upstairs for additional living space, providing both comfort & peaceful, quiet living. The stunning high-end kitchen features quartz counters, SS appliances, farmhouse sink, a new gas stove (2024), new dishwasher (2024), & is perfect for everyday living & entertaining. A warm & inviting living room w/a gas FP creates the perfect place to relax. The heated & cooled sunroom offers year-round enjoyment & opens through a brand-new patio door (2025) to a spacious composite deck overlooking the backyard. The fully remodeled primary suite offers a fresh, modern retreat (2024), while the 4th bed is currently being used as a home office & includes a walk-in closet & private half bath, making it an ideal guest suite or flexible living space. The 3rd bay of the garage has been transformed into an exceptional entertaining space featuring a custom-built bar, custom accent wall, & woodburning stove. The garage also includes a workshop, attic storage, & the gun safe stays w/the home. Thoughtfully maintained w/numerous updates, including a new furnace (2026), new AC (2024), new front & screen doors (2024), & septic aeration pump replaced (2024). Outside, enjoy the garden area along w/mature apple & peach trees, creating the perfect setting to relax & appreciate the peaceful surroundings. Pre-inspected!

4489 Palmyra Road, Palmyra

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ CA1044321 MLS

Gorgeous remodeled home that will welcome you in and make you fall in love with it!!!! Home has all new doors (interior and exterior with hardware) and baseboard, trim and light fixtures (interior and exterior). The flooring has all been replaced.The kitchen has been remodeled with all new refaced cabinets, appliances, quartz countertops, backsplash, faucets, under cabinet lighting. Primary Bath completely remodeled with new shower, toilet, vanity and lighting. Half bath has new toilet and vanity. New ceilings fans have been added through the house. Comfy family room has added additional square feet to the lower level. Beautiful window treatments have accentuated the windows. New Sump Pump and outside hydrants. Black wrought iron fence has been installed around the back yard. Store your garden and yard equipment or work in the shop. Electrical wiring has been added to the workshop. Come and fall in love with this beauty!!!

186 W Sherman Street, Palmyra

Start Your Search

Alysa Bunting - Owner | Designated Managing Broker

Alysa Bunting, a driven real estate expert, spearheads Indigo Realty, LLC. Her passion for property investment traces back to her childhood, with Monopoly ranking among her top games. Alysa's real estate journey began in her early 20s, marking her entry with the acquisition of a rental property. Subsequently, she ventured into the retail and service sectors, establishing multiple businesses in Southern Illinois. Her portfolio boasts numerous investment properties, both acquired and sold. 2011 was a pivotal year for Alysa; she earned her real estate license and embraced motherhood, now a proud parent to Aiden, Daisy, and Vaithan. In 2022, she launched Indigo Realty, LLC, reflecting her commitment to the industry. With roots in Williamson County and an alma mater in Marion, Alysa's vision was clear: to anchor her real estate enterprise in Williamson County. Her husband, Tim Moulton, hails from Johnston City, where their children attend school, influencing the location of Indigo Realty's office. The tight-knit community vibe resonates with Alysa, driving her to invest and expand her venture there. Alysa's ambition? To be the first name that springs to mind for real estate transactions in Southern Illinois. At Indigo Realty, the mantra is clear: comprehensive services with a personal touch.

Learn More

T.J. Martin - Broker

Looking for a dedicated and experienced real estate agent in Southern Illinois? Look no further than TJ! With 14 years of entrepreneurship under his belt, including running his own construction company, TJ brings a unique hands-on approach to every real estate transaction. When he's not busy remodeling homes or helping clients find their dream properties, you can catch TJ out on the golf course or fishing in the great outdoors. But don't let his laid-back vibe fool you - TJ is all about hard work and ensuring his clients get the best possible real estate experience. Whether you're a first-time buyer, seasoned investor, or looking to expand your real estate portfolio, TJ's construction background gives him a keen eye for value and potential. He's not just about buying and selling homes; he's about building long-lasting relationships and making a positive impact on his clients' lives. Ready to open the door to your new home or investment opportunity? TJ is here to guide you every step of the way. Give him a call today and let's make your real estate dreams a reality! #SouthernIllinoisRealtor #RealEstateExpert #HomeSweetHome

Learn More

Allison Hasler - Broker

Wife, Mother, Combat Veteran, Business Owner, Podcaster. After a masters degree and 11 year career in public health, Allison traded in her public health hat for entrepreneurship and business development. As Southern Illinois Vacation Rentals grew, Allison stepped out of her role with the City of Marion in September of 2021 to devote full time to the ever-growing property management business. Allison Hasler is a proud US Veteran, serving in the Illinois National Guard from 2000-2006. On her deployment in Iraq in December 2004-February 2005, she earned several medals including her Combat Action Badge and Good Conduct Medal for the roles she served as a Combat Lifesaver, Radio Transmission Operator for Log Base Seitz, and Truck Driver (88M) for the 1544th Transportation Company out of Paris, Illinois.

Learn More

Chellie McGuire - Broker

When she's not curled up with a good book on her porch or working on her latest sewing or crochet project, you can find Chellie spending time with her grandson and grown children—her favorite people in the world. With a doctorate in education and over 20 years of experience as a teacher and school administrator, Chellie brings a lifelong passion for learning and a heart for helping others into everything she does. Now, she's channeling that same energy into real estate. Chellie understands that buying or selling a home isn’t just a transaction—it’s a transition. With every move comes new beginnings, big emotions, and endless possibilities. She’s here to guide her clients through it all with patience, care, and a steady hand. Whether you're looking for your first home, getting ready to downsize, or just chasing your next adventure, Chellie’s ready to walk with you every step of the way. She may be new to real estate, but she’s no stranger to big decisions, life changes, and putting people first. Let’s start your next chapter—give Chellie a call today!

Learn More

Rodney Laningham - Broker

Rodney Laningham brings a rare mix of professionalism, integrity, and real-world experience to Indigo Realty. A 1981 graduate of John A. Logan College, Rodney earned his bachelor’s degree in Agriculture and Plant & Soil Science from Southern Illinois University in 1984. Rodney recently retired after 45 years with UPS, where consistency, reliability, and customer service weren’t optional—they were the standard. Alongside that career, he’s spent over 30 years as a licensed auctioneer and real estate managing broker, licensed in multiple states, giving him deep expertise in pricing, property value, and negotiating with confidence. He’s a graduate of the Certified Auctioneer Institute at Indiana University and has served on the Auction Advisory Board for the Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation. Rodney is also well-known across Southern Illinois as the lead cattle auctioneer at Cattlemen’s Livestock in Wayne City and the Southern Illinois Equine Sale in Goreville. Rooted in the region, Rodney operates a small cattle farm near Crab Orchard that has been in his family since 1854—making him fifth generation to care for the land. He has a long history of supporting charities, churches, civic organizations, and individuals in need, and he’s proud to be involved in community-driven work that makes a lasting impact. When he’s not working with clients, Rodney and his wife, Lynda, enjoy camping (especially in National Parks), and he’s an avid collector of antique tractors, tools, toys, and farm-related memorabilia. If you’re looking for someone steady, knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in Southern Illinois, Rodney is the kind of agent you’ll be glad you called.

Learn More